‘We Are Not Equipped to Deal With This’: Migrant Surge Overwhelms U.S. Border (2024)

At a remote spot in the Arizona desert, near a hole in the border wall, dozens of migrants huddled over wood fires.

After fleeing war in Sudan, violent gangs in Central America or Mexican cartels, the men had all crossed into the United States illegally, walked on foot over rugged terrain for hours, and arrived at this outpost exhausted, hungry and cold.

They wanted to turn themselves into the authorities to ask for asylum, but were stranded here, miles away from the closest town, Sásabe.

Then, as temperatures dropped on Tuesday night, a convoy of Border Patrol agents rolled in, loaded the men into a van to be processed and sped away — off to search for more people in need of rescue.

“We are not equipped to deal with this,” Scott Carmon, a Border Patrol watch commander, said while surveying the muddy encampment. “It’s a humanitarian disaster.”

This is the crisis unfolding at the southern border, as migrant encounters once again hit record levels and test the capacity of American law enforcement to contain an explosion of illegal crossings with far-reaching repercussions for the Biden administration.

Thousands of migrants are arriving at the border every day, trekking from the farthest reaches of the globe, from Africa to Asia to South America, driven by relentless violence, desperation and poverty.

In May, the Biden administration briefly celebrated when crossings declined, even after pandemic-era border restrictions were lifted and many feared the floodgates would open. But the numbers have spiked in recent months, provoking sharp criticism from both parties and fears within the administration that the issue will damage Democrats’ electoral future.

“In terms of migrants per day, December 2023 is bigger than any average we have ever seen,” said Adam Isacson, a migration expert at the Washington Office on Latin America. “Every official who is commenting on it, on all levels, says they’re near or past the breaking point.”

Secretary of State Antony J. Blinken and other senior officials traveled to Mexico on Wednesday to discuss the spike in migration with President Andrés Manuel López Obrador, while American officials monitored a new caravan of more than 2,000 migrants moving north through the country toward the United States.

The caravan is unlikely to make it to the United States, experts said, but it has drawn significant media attention to the tide of migrants who have already crossed the border en masse.

On Thursday, Mr. López Obrador praised the meeting between the two countries, saying that President Biden understands that migration “is a social problem and that it cannot be solved with coercive measures alone.”

The Mexican Foreign Ministry said in a statement that both delegations agreed to meet again in Washington in January.

Mexico has been a stalwart enforcer of U.S. border restrictions, detaining a record number of migrants this year, government figures show. But in December, the National Migration Institute, a government agency, suspended migrant deportations from the country because of a lack of funding, according to an institute official who was not authorized to speak publicly.

Experts and officials are still piecing together exactly what’s behind the recent migration swell.

Among the leading theories: larger numbers of Mexicans who seem to be fleeing cartel turf battles across the country; rumors about the end of a key legal pathway that may have prompted a rush to cross; and smugglers who have pushed desperate people of all nationalities to try to enter at increasingly remote parts of the border.

“If you move to a place that’s super remote, there won’t be a lot of agents on staff and that increases your chances of being released into the U.S.,” Mr. Isacson said. “There is nowhere to put people. They can’t hold you.”

Izzeddin, a 32-year-old migrant from Sudan, was among about a dozen men from his homeland at the Arizona encampment on Tuesday. He sipped sugary coffee provided by an aid group, No More Deaths, that has helped keep migrants alive with blankets, food and 911 calls to address life-threatening injuries.

“We came here because we need protection,” said Izzeddin, who asked to be identified by only his first name, fearing reprisals against his family.

A raging civil war in Sudan has driven millions from their homes, including these men, who said they lost family members and left loved ones in refugee camps to trek to the United States.

In Sudan, Izzeddin said, “we saw people being killed, raped.” He and his companions, he said, were all waiting for one thing: “border patrol to come pick us up and give us protection.”

Often, migrants who get to the United States and ask for asylum — protection from political or other persecution at home — do not actually get their claims screened upon arrival. Because of the limited capacity to detain people at the border, many are instead released with a court date for a judge to evaluate their cases. The process can take years.

In Arizona, border officials closed a key port of entry to legal crossings in early December to focus on the unlawful ones.

Mr. Carmon, the Border Patrol watch commander, pleaded for more resources. “Give us more help, give us FEMA,” he said.

Last week, workers from No More Deaths evacuated migrants caught in a rainstorm to a nearby Border Patrol facility, a spokeswoman for the group said.

“If we had a flooded city and people needed to get evacuated, they would drive National Guard trucks, those big cattle trucks, and put our citizens in them,” Mr. Carmon said. “Why they’re not down here helping us transport these people to safety and warmth, I don’t know.”

For Izzeddin, being exposed to the elements in the desert felt a lot safer than staying in Sudan.

“It doesn’t matter if it’s cold,” he said. “There is peace here.”